Fork us on GitHub

Should we use Gradients?

With the new pipeline on Android gradients perform much better
Should we use Gradients?

Should we use Gradients?

With the latest version of the Android port we fixed a long running bug in gradient drawing on Android. Gradients should now work correctly and will also be performant potentially even faster than images on Android. Our standing recommendation is to avoid gradients as they pose a memory/performance penalty on most platforms and so this change raises the question of using gradients back into the forefront.

We gave this some thought and decided to keep our existing recommendation to avoid gradients in favor of images but soften it. Performance of gradients isn’t tested as extensively across platforms, we don’t use them at all in our themes and so they are just not as robust as other elements.

In order to get gradients to perform we implemented them natively on the host OS’s which means they might look different on the target device. This might work reasonably well but might pose issues in some cases.

To make matters worse our gradients are really trivial in terms of functionality. They don’t support orientation, breaks, alpha, paint (shapes) or a multitude of other capabilities that make gradients into a powerful tool.

So Why Fix Gradients?

We’d like to fix gradients completely, currently our graphics capabilities still lag behind those of Java2D/FX. That’s not a horrible place to be in as both of these API’s weren’t designed for todays mobile environments and their oddities.

This is true for the most part but we do have at least one thing which Java2D doesn’t have: perspective transform

Eventually we think the road for API maturity is paved with small steps, fixing gradients today is just such a step in a long road that might lead to gradient filled shapes with complex gradient rules. At that point the decision between using a gradient and an image might not be as clear cut.

Share this Post:

Posted by Shai Almog

Shai is the co-founder of Codename One. He's been a professional programmer for over 25 years. During that time he has worked with dozens of companies including Sun Microsystems.
For more follow Shai on Twitter & github.