Fork us on GitHub

Synchronous InfiniteContainer

When violating the EDT is a subject to debate
Synchronous InfiniteContainer

Synchronous InfiniteContainer

InfiniteContainer and InfiniteScrollAdapter revolutionized the way we think about Codename One. Up until their introduction we advocated lists for large sets of components and this is no longer the case.

However, InfiniteContainer has a controversial feature even within out team. It violates the EDT on purpose…​

InfiniteContainer allows you to "fetch" data dynamically into the container as the user scrolls down. The definition of "fetch" is problematic though. Up until now the fetch method was invoked in a separate thread. This was documented in the class but it is pretty problematic as the method returns an array of components.

In practice creating a component in a separate shouldn’t pose a problem, yes it does violate the core Codename One principal of always doing everything on the EDT but construction should work. However, this does include some problems:

  • The EDT violation detection marks such code as violating

  • The most common case (networking) already works rather well off the EDT and doesn’t need a separate thread

  • This is inconsistent with the rest of Codename One

  • There are some edge cases where this might trigger a real EDT violation e.g. if component construction triggers an event thus creating a race condition with the EDT

So to workaround this we added the new method: protected boolean isAsync().

If you override this method to return false the fetch method will be invoked on the EDT but this might break compatibility so currently this method is set to return true.

We currently plan to change the method to return false by default within a couple of weeks. This might change based on feedback we get from developers.

Share this Post:

Posted by Shai Almog

Shai is the co-founder of Codename One. He's been a professional programmer for over 25 years. During that time he has worked with dozens of companies including Sun Microsystems.
For more follow Shai on Twitter & github.